Do carrier 'vetting' services unfairly tarnish too many good carriers, or bring them out of the dark?

As brokers attempt to stiffen their defenses against fraudulent players in the spot market with sometimes tough carrier-selection criteria, a multiplicity of carrier-vetting and compliance-monitoring services also are on the rise. If you're independent and haven't encountered them, read more about some of the services in past Overdrive coverage via these links: 

**'Fraud Apocalypse: Brokers circling the wagons, shutting carriers out of freight
**Big change for Carrier Assure? Vetting tool acknowledges shortcomings
**The third parties following you around the freight networks

The following two-question survey asks for input and opinion on the effectiveness of what's been described as something of a cottage industry of such services, growing at the intersection of the broker/carrier relationship. Weigh in below with your experience.